In languages that support both, &&/|| have higher precedence than and/or, so using them with assignment can lead to unexpected results; 1. Use &&/|| for boolean logic in expressions to avoid precedence issues; 2. Reserve and/or for control flow due to their low precedence; 3. Always use parentheses in complex expressions to ensure clarity and correctness; 4. Know your language—Python and JavaScript avoid the trap by only offering one set of operators, while Ruby, Perl, and PHP require careful distinction.

When working with logical expressions in programming—especially in languages like Python or JavaScript—understanding the difference between the logical operators (and, or) and their symbolic counterparts (&&, ||) is crucial. But more importantly, knowing how short-circuiting and operator precedence interact can prevent subtle bugs. Let’s break this down.

Short-Circuiting Works the Same, But Precedence Differs

Both and/or and &&/|| (depending on the language) support short-circuit evaluation:

• a && b or a and b: if a is false, b is never evaluated.
• a || b or a or b: if a is true, b is never evaluated.

This is useful for things like:

if user and user.is_active():
    user.do_something()

Here, user.is_active() only runs if user exists—thanks to short-circuiting.

But the real trap lies in operator precedence.

The Precedence Trap: and/or vs. &&/||

In Python, there’s no && or ||. You use and, or, not. But in Ruby, Perl, or some other languages, both symbolic (&&, ||) and word-based (and, or) operators exist—and they have different precedence.

Let’s take Ruby as a clear example:

# Example 1
a = true && false
# => false

# Example 2
a = true and false
# SyntaxError! Or unexpected behavior due to precedence.

Why? Because and and or have much lower precedence than =, while && and || have higher precedence.

So this:

x = true and false

is interpreted as:

(x = true) and false

Which means x becomes true, and the whole expression evaluates to false, but x is already assigned.

Compare with:

x = true && false

Which is:

x = (true && false)

So x becomes false.

This is a massive trap when combining assignment and logic.

Practical Implications

1. Use && and || for boolean logic in expressions

If you're doing conditional assignments or complex logic, stick to the high-precedence operators:

# Safe and predictable
logged_in = user_valid && token_valid || temp_access

2. Avoid and/or in complex expressions

They’re better suited for control flow or joining statements:

# Idiomatic in Ruby for flow
process_data or raise "No data"

Here, or acts like a low-precedence separator—similar to ||, but safer in chains because it doesn’t bind tightly.

3. Always use parentheses when in doubt

Even if you know the precedence, others might not:

x = (user_active? && has_permission?) || admin_override

This is clearer and immune to misinterpretation.

Language-Specific Notes

• Python: Only has and, or, not. No &&/||. So precedence is consistent (but still lower than comparisons).
• Ruby/Perl: Both sets exist. &&/|| are for logic; and/or are for control flow.
• JavaScript: Only &&/||. No and/or. So no such trap, but short-circuiting still applies.
• PHP: Has both, and yes—and/or have different precedence than &&/||.

Example in PHP:

$x = true and false;
var_dump($x); // true!

Because it’s ($x = true) and false.

But:

$x = true && false;
var_dump($x); // false

Key Takeaways

• ? Short-circuiting works the same for both forms.
• ?? Precedence differs: &&/|| bind tighter than and/or.
• ? Don’t mix and/or with assignment unless you want the low precedence.
• ? Always use parentheses in complex logic.
• ? Know your language: in Python, no issue; in Ruby/PHP, big issue.

Basically, if your language offers both, treat and/or like flow-control tools, and &&/|| like logical operators in expressions. Mixing them up can lead to bugs that are hard to spot.

The above is the detailed content of Short-Circuiting and Precedence Traps: `&&`/`||` vs. `and`/`or`. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!