Ext4 is best for general desktop or laptop use and environments requiring maximum stability, offering reliability and simplicity but lacking modern features like snapshots or checksums. 2. Btrfs is ideal for systems needing snapshots, rollbacks, and data integrity features, suitable for home NAS, workstations, and future-proof setups, though RAID 5/6 should be avoided due to instability. 3. XFS excels in enterprise environments with large files, databases, or virtualization, providing high scalability and throughput but does not support shrinking and performs poorly with many small files. Choose based on use case: Ext4 for stability, Btrfs for features, XFS for performance at scale.

When choosing a filesystem for Linux, three options often stand out: Ext4, Btrfs, and XFS. Each has its strengths and trade-offs depending on your use case—whether it’s desktop use, enterprise servers, or large-scale storage. Here's a practical comparison to help you decide which fits best.

1. Ext4: The Reliable Workhorse

Ext4 (Fourth Extended Filesystem) is the most widely used Linux filesystem and the default on many distributions like Ubuntu and CentOS (older versions).

Pros:

• Stable and mature: Decades of real-world use, thoroughly tested.
• Good performance for general use: Fast file access, especially on smaller to medium-sized systems.
• Simple to manage: Tools like e2fsck are reliable and well-documented.
• Backward compatible with Ext2/Ext3.

Cons:

• No built-in snapshots or checksums: Lacks modern features like data integrity verification.
• No native support for pooling or RAID—relies on LVM or mdadm.
• Fragmentation can become an issue over time, especially with heavy write loads.

Best for: Desktop systems, traditional servers, and environments where stability and simplicity matter most.

2. Btrfs: The Feature-Rich Modern Option

Btrfs (B-tree Filesystem) was designed to bring modern capabilities to Linux, inspired by ZFS but integrated into the mainline kernel.

Pros:

• Snapshots and rollbacks: Great for system updates or backups.
• Built-in RAID support (0, 1, 10, and limited 5/6).
• Copy-on-write (CoW): Helps prevent data corruption.
• Checksums for data and metadata: Detects silent data corruption.
• Subvolumes and transparent compression (e.g., zlib, zstd).
• Online resizing and defragmentation.

Cons:

• RAID 5/6 still considered unstable—use with caution.
• Can be slower under heavy random write loads due to CoW.
• More complex to troubleshoot when things go wrong.
• Still maturing: Some advanced features aren’t as battle-tested as Ext4 or XFS.

Best for: Systems needing snapshots (like workstations with frequent updates), home servers, or NAS setups where data integrity and flexibility are key.

? Many now use Btrfs with RAID 1 or plain disks for safer operation, avoiding RAID 5/6 entirely.

3. XFS: The Scalable Powerhouse

XFS excels in handling large files and high-throughput environments. It’s the default on RHEL, CentOS, and Fedora for server installations.

Pros:

• Excellent performance with large files (ideal for video editing, databases, VM images).
• Highly scalable: Handles multi-terabyte filesystems with ease.
• Robust journaling and fast crash recovery.
• Supports metadata checksums (from kernel 4.15 ).
• Efficient allocation for large storage pools.

Cons:

• Cannot shrink (shrink) the filesystem—only grow.
• No built-in snapshots or encryption (relies on LVM for snapshots).
• Slower with many small files compared to Ext4 or Btrfs.
• Less flexible for dynamic changes.

Best for: Enterprise servers, media storage, databases, and environments with large sequential I/O.

Quick Decision Guide

Final Thoughts

• Stick with Ext4 if you want “it just works” reliability.
• Choose Btrfs if you value snapshots, checksums, and modern storage features—just avoid unstable RAID modes.
• Go with XFS when dealing with large files and high throughput, especially in enterprise environments.

None is universally “best”—it comes down to your priorities: stability, features, or performance at scale.

Basically, pick based on what you’re doing, not what’s trendy.

The above is the detailed content of Comparing Linux Filesystems: Ext4 vs. Btrfs vs. XFS. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!