


Ask Forgiveness, Not Permission: When Is Exception Handling Better Than Preemptive Checks?
Dec 30, 2024 pm 09:59 PM"Ask Forgiveness Not Permission": A Technical Explanation
In programming, the phrase "ask forgiveness not permission" describes two contrasting coding styles:
"Ask for Permission" Style:
if can_do_operation(): perform_operation() else: handle_error_case()
"Ask for Forgiveness" Style:
try: perform_operation() except Unable_to_perform: handle_error_case()
In the "ask for permission" approach, the presence of the can_do_operation() check prevents the perform_operation() call from executing if the operation cannot be performed. However, this approach relies on the accuracy of the can_do_operation() check, which may not always be reliable in dynamic environments or when dealing with external resources.
Benefits of "Ask for Forgiveness"
The "ask for forgiveness" style offers several benefits:
- Handles Concurrent Situations: In multithreaded or multi-resource environments, the conditions may change between the check and the operation, making the "ask for permission" approach ineffective.
- Avoids Overly Restrictive Checks: "Ask for permission" requires defining precise and comprehensive criteria, which can be challenging and error-prone. The "ask for forgiveness" approach allows for more flexibility and avoids the unintentional exclusion of valid operations.
Example: Instance Attribute Access
In your example, you inquire about the use of "ask for forgiveness" when accessing instance attributes. While normally considered a programmer error, accessing a non-existent attribute can be a valid scenario, such as when dealing with optional object parts.
Instead of testing for the existence of an attribute (foo.bar) with an exception handler, it's more Pythonic to check if the attribute is not None. For optional attributes, the bar attribute is typically initialized to None initially and set to a meaningful value if available. This allows for the following test:
if foo.bar is not None: handle_optional_part(foo.bar) else: default_handling()
Conclusion
The "ask forgiveness not permission" principle recommends embracing exceptions as a natural part of program execution, particularly when dealing with optional functionality or external resource interactions. It provides greater flexibility and adaptability in dynamic and concurrent environments, while still enabling error handling through exception handling mechanisms.
The above is the detailed content of Ask Forgiveness, Not Permission: When Is Exception Handling Better Than Preemptive Checks?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!

Hot AI Tools

Undress AI Tool
Undress images for free

Undresser.AI Undress
AI-powered app for creating realistic nude photos

AI Clothes Remover
Online AI tool for removing clothes from photos.

Clothoff.io
AI clothes remover

Video Face Swap
Swap faces in any video effortlessly with our completely free AI face swap tool!

Hot Article

Hot Tools

Notepad++7.3.1
Easy-to-use and free code editor

SublimeText3 Chinese version
Chinese version, very easy to use

Zend Studio 13.0.1
Powerful PHP integrated development environment

Dreamweaver CS6
Visual web development tools

SublimeText3 Mac version
God-level code editing software (SublimeText3)

Hot Topics

Polymorphism is a core concept in Python object-oriented programming, referring to "one interface, multiple implementations", allowing for unified processing of different types of objects. 1. Polymorphism is implemented through method rewriting. Subclasses can redefine parent class methods. For example, the spoke() method of Animal class has different implementations in Dog and Cat subclasses. 2. The practical uses of polymorphism include simplifying the code structure and enhancing scalability, such as calling the draw() method uniformly in the graphical drawing program, or handling the common behavior of different characters in game development. 3. Python implementation polymorphism needs to satisfy: the parent class defines a method, and the child class overrides the method, but does not require inheritance of the same parent class. As long as the object implements the same method, this is called the "duck type". 4. Things to note include the maintenance

Parameters are placeholders when defining a function, while arguments are specific values ??passed in when calling. 1. Position parameters need to be passed in order, and incorrect order will lead to errors in the result; 2. Keyword parameters are specified by parameter names, which can change the order and improve readability; 3. Default parameter values ??are assigned when defined to avoid duplicate code, but variable objects should be avoided as default values; 4. args and *kwargs can handle uncertain number of parameters and are suitable for general interfaces or decorators, but should be used with caution to maintain readability.

Iterators are objects that implement __iter__() and __next__() methods. The generator is a simplified version of iterators, which automatically implement these methods through the yield keyword. 1. The iterator returns an element every time he calls next() and throws a StopIteration exception when there are no more elements. 2. The generator uses function definition to generate data on demand, saving memory and supporting infinite sequences. 3. Use iterators when processing existing sets, use a generator when dynamically generating big data or lazy evaluation, such as loading line by line when reading large files. Note: Iterable objects such as lists are not iterators. They need to be recreated after the iterator reaches its end, and the generator can only traverse it once.

A class method is a method defined in Python through the @classmethod decorator. Its first parameter is the class itself (cls), which is used to access or modify the class state. It can be called through a class or instance, which affects the entire class rather than a specific instance; for example, in the Person class, the show_count() method counts the number of objects created; when defining a class method, you need to use the @classmethod decorator and name the first parameter cls, such as the change_var(new_value) method to modify class variables; the class method is different from the instance method (self parameter) and static method (no automatic parameters), and is suitable for factory methods, alternative constructors, and management of class variables. Common uses include:

The key to dealing with API authentication is to understand and use the authentication method correctly. 1. APIKey is the simplest authentication method, usually placed in the request header or URL parameters; 2. BasicAuth uses username and password for Base64 encoding transmission, which is suitable for internal systems; 3. OAuth2 needs to obtain the token first through client_id and client_secret, and then bring the BearerToken in the request header; 4. In order to deal with the token expiration, the token management class can be encapsulated and automatically refreshed the token; in short, selecting the appropriate method according to the document and safely storing the key information is the key.

Python's magicmethods (or dunder methods) are special methods used to define the behavior of objects, which start and end with a double underscore. 1. They enable objects to respond to built-in operations, such as addition, comparison, string representation, etc.; 2. Common use cases include object initialization and representation (__init__, __repr__, __str__), arithmetic operations (__add__, __sub__, __mul__) and comparison operations (__eq__, ___lt__); 3. When using it, make sure that their behavior meets expectations. For example, __repr__ should return expressions of refactorable objects, and arithmetic methods should return new instances; 4. Overuse or confusing things should be avoided.

Pythonmanagesmemoryautomaticallyusingreferencecountingandagarbagecollector.Referencecountingtrackshowmanyvariablesrefertoanobject,andwhenthecountreacheszero,thememoryisfreed.However,itcannothandlecircularreferences,wheretwoobjectsrefertoeachotherbuta

Python's garbage collection mechanism automatically manages memory through reference counting and periodic garbage collection. Its core method is reference counting, which immediately releases memory when the number of references of an object is zero; but it cannot handle circular references, so a garbage collection module (gc) is introduced to detect and clean the loop. Garbage collection is usually triggered when the reference count decreases during program operation, the allocation and release difference exceeds the threshold, or when gc.collect() is called manually. Users can turn off automatic recycling through gc.disable(), manually execute gc.collect(), and adjust thresholds to achieve control through gc.set_threshold(). Not all objects participate in loop recycling. If objects that do not contain references are processed by reference counting, it is built-in
